Rowyn (rowyn) wrote,
Rowyn
rowyn

Punished Enough

I wasn't going to say anything about the AIG bonuses. Really, I wasn't, because I think the whole furor is silly, making a huge issue over a tiny symptom.

Then I read this.

Short version:

It is not possible, under current US tax law, for an employee to return income to his employer and have that money not counted as part of the employee's income.

So, those who got bonuses have the following options:

(A) return the full bonus to AIG, in which case they will owe taxes on the full amount of the bonus anyway.
(B) donate the full bonus to charity, in which case the alternative minimum tax means they probably still have to pay taxes on all or most of it.
(C) keep the bonus and use it to pay state and federal taxes which -- if Congress passes the House's version of the punish-AIG-bill -- will probably exceed 100% of the bonus amount.

Y'know, I am not without sympathy for those who are angry that AIG's financial division employees still had a job and got fat "retention" bonuses (even if they'd quit) regardless of their performance at their job.

But the government response here leaves me truly infuriated. These employees didn't do anything but accept what they were offered for legal employment, and this after-the-fact "no, actually, give us back that $1,000,000 bonus or we'll throw you to the mob, plus you have to pay us an additional $280,000 or we'll jail you for tax evasion" is just nauseating. No one who hasn't been convicted of a crime should be subject to fines of 130% of income.

What a mess.
Subscribe

  • The Dunning-Kruger Effect, But It’s Me

    This struck me as a good blog post prompt: “think of an occasion where you exemplified the Dunning-Kruger effect.” I’ll pick an amusing area that…

  • Free Speech and Compelled Speech

    I have a pretty straightforward take on the first amendment: I agree with it, and I agree with the general thrust of courts to interpret its…

  • March 2021 in Review

    Health & Fitness I didn’t make it to exercising 20 times in March: 17. Even so, total effort over the course of the month was pretty similar.…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 19 comments

  • The Dunning-Kruger Effect, But It’s Me

    This struck me as a good blog post prompt: “think of an occasion where you exemplified the Dunning-Kruger effect.” I’ll pick an amusing area that…

  • Free Speech and Compelled Speech

    I have a pretty straightforward take on the first amendment: I agree with it, and I agree with the general thrust of courts to interpret its…

  • March 2021 in Review

    Health & Fitness I didn’t make it to exercising 20 times in March: 17. Even so, total effort over the course of the month was pretty similar.…