I think I will explain my rating scale in this entry, while I'm here. I use a 1-10 scale because I find that on a 1-5 scale, I pretty much only use 3 and 4. I am not particularly trying to be objective in the numbers: this is "How much fun I had reading it". So books that suit my tastes well are going to get a higher rating than ones that use tropes that make me cringe, even if both are well-written for what they are.
1-4: Most likely, I'll never use these. Anything that doesn't rate at least a 5, I probably won't finish and most likely won't write up even if I do.
5: I am not sorry that I read it, but not impressed either. Had some enjoyable parts but didn't seem well-done and/or relied heavily on tropes that I don't care for.
6: I liked it, but still felt underwhelmed.
7: Pretty good, but perhaps flat in parts -- maybe using tropes I don't like, or uneven writing, or lacking in a certain sparkle.
8: Solid, definitely enjoyable, well worth reading.
9: I loved it. Could find fault with it if I put my mind to it, but nothing that significantly marred my enjoyment. This is probably the highest rating I'll use.
10: I loved it and can't think of anything that could have been done better. I can be awfully nitpicky, so I'm unlikely to ever use this.