Rowyn (rowyn) wrote,

H.M.S. Surprise, Patrick O'Brian

I liked H.M.S. Surprise about as well as Master and Commander. I have taken to looking up some of the sea jargon and can now remember the difference between foremast and mizzenmast and what a stay is, and what it means to miss stays (although I don't actually know the mechanics behind the failure.) Overall, still about as ignorant as Dr. Maturin, though. The battles are no longer wholly incomprehensible, but still largely.

For all that, I was glad for the sea-scenes of this book, where Aubrey is comfortable and at home and everything makes sense, in its jargon-laden way.

There are scenes in the story which are amazingly vivid in my mind, like Stephen Maturin being fed by his very young and scolding native guide, who clearly thinks he needs a keeper. She is nine or ten, and she is right: he does. I'm at the stage in the series where I don't want to discuss details much in my review for fear of spoilers. (Spoilers will probably be in the comments, when I talk to alltoseek about the book.) I felt rather sorry for Dr. Maturin in most of this book, while at the same time keenly aware that he had brought the worst of his troubles on himself. I think my stock of pity for him is about exhausted, though. If he's going to insist on making himself miserable, that's his own problem. I'm rating the book overall an 8 of 10.

I think I am going to take a break from the Aubreyad and read something else from my stack o' library books, which has six non-Aubreyad books in it that I really ought to read or return. And while I do want to read more Aubrey/Maturin stories, I've read enough of those two that I will not be annoyed at other books for not being about them.
Tags: book review, books, review

  • How Do I Outline?

    I’ve had three different friends ask me variations on “how do you outline?” in the last month or so. My response goes something like this: Sure,…

  • Outlines and Measuring Progress

    I'm trying to get back in the habit of focusing on "draft completion" rather than word count. But my methodology is all about incremental steps:…

  • "Goals Don't Work" and the Utility of Experimenting on Yourself

    So scientific research shows that, on average, setting public goals isn’t constructive. In general, people who proclaim “I will do [X]” are less…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.